What to read after “Butcher's Crossing” by John Williams: a list matched by tropes, mood and atmosphere. Under each book you will see what it has in common.
After Comanche raiders kill his brother's family and carry off his niece Debbie, Amos Edwards and Martin Pauley, the orphan the Edwards family took in, spend years searching the Texas plains for her. The long hunt hardens Amos's hatred and strains his bond with Martin, who wants to bring the girl home.
After her father is shot dead in 1870s Arkansas, fourteen-year-old Mattie Ross hires Rooster Cogburn, a one-eyed U.S. marshal with a taste for whiskey, to hunt the killer into Indian Territory. A Texas Ranger joins them, and the three ride into a hard country where justice is personal.
Two former Texas Rangers drive a herd of cattle north to Montana, leading a ragged crew across rivers, drought and hostile country. The long journey tests the old friendship of the two men and the loyalties of everyone who follows them.
In the 1850s, a teenage runaway known only as the kid drifts into a borderland of scalphunters and broken towns. He joins the Glanton gang, whose campaign against Apache raiders becomes indiscriminate slaughter, shadowed by a pale, learned judge who preaches war as the highest law.
A quiet stranger rides into a Wyoming valley and hires on with homesteaders Joe and Marian Starrett. The boy Bob idolises him, but Shane's skill with a gun pulls him back toward a past he wants to leave when a cattle baron moves against the settlers.
In 1870 Texas, an ageing widower who reads newspapers aloud to frontier audiences agrees to carry a ten-year-old girl south to her relatives. She was taken by Kiowa years earlier and has forgotten English, and the long journey is dangerous for them both.
Frontiersman Hugh Glass is mauled by a bear and left for dead by his companions, who take his rifle and supplies. He crawls out of the wilderness and sets out on a long journey to find the men who abandoned him.
A nameless cowpuncher on a Wyoming ranch falls for the new schoolteacher from Vermont while feuding with a ranch hand named Trampas. His code of honour is tested by a cattle thief, a lynching and a duel, in a territory where the law is still being made.
Stolen from a comfortable California home, the dog Buck is sold into the Klondike gold rush and forced to haul sleds through frozen wilderness. Amid cruelty and hardship he discovers a wildness within himself that calls him away from men.
Jane Withersteen runs a Utah ranch under pressure from Mormon elders who want her to marry one of them. When the gunslinger Lassiter arrives looking for the men who destroyed his family, his quarrel with the town's leaders becomes hers, and she must decide how far she will go to protect the people she has taken under her wing.
Eli and Charlie Sisters are hired killers riding to California to find a prospector. As the brothers travel, Eli grows tired of the violence of their trade and begins to imagine another life, while Charlie insists that the job must be finished.
In a militarised near-future American West, a young woman flees an arranged marriage and hides in a travelling library. The librarians turn out to carry banned books and help people cross the border, and she finds a purpose, a community, and a woman she loves.
In 1925 the explorer Percy Fawcett walked into the Amazon to find a fabled civilization he called Z, and never came out. Decades later a journalist follows the same trails, sifting clues and rumors to learn what became of the missing expedition.
In an alternate 1878, Karen Memery works at a brothel in Seattle. When a badly injured woman arrives with a ruthless man on her trail, Karen is pulled into a hunt for a serial killer, a corrupt election and a mess of dangerous inventions.
Marcus Aquila, a young Roman officer, arrives in Britain after his father's legion vanished in the north. When the legion's eagle standard is rumoured to survive, Marcus and his British companion Esca travel beyond Hadrian's Wall to recover it and clear his family's name.
Spoiled Southern belle Scarlett O'Hara sees her world torn apart by the American Civil War. Determined to rebuild her family's plantation and her fortune, she schemes and marries her way through the ruins of the Old South, chasing a man she cannot have.
Robert Jordan, an American volunteer, joins a band of Republican guerrillas in the Spanish mountains to blow up a bridge. Over a few days he falls for Maria, a young woman scarred by war, and weighs duty, love and the near certainty that the mission will cost him his life.
A young woman in colonial Korea, Sunja, leaves home for Japan with a husband she barely knows and raises a family that lives as outsiders for generations. Through war and poverty, the household holds on to its dignity and its secrets.
Dana, a Black writer in 1976 California, is suddenly pulled back in time to a Maryland plantation, where she saves the life of a white boy named Rufus. Again and again she is dragged into the past, where she must survive slavery and protect Rufus to keep her own future alive.
During the German occupation of France, a blind girl and her father flee Paris for the walled city of Saint-Malo, carrying a valuable jewel. In Germany, an orphan with a gift for radio repairs is drawn into the war machine. Their separate paths move slowly toward the same besieged town in August 1944.
Bombardier Yossarian wants to survive the war and go home, but every attempt to be grounded runs into a rule that answers itself: to be excused he must ask, and asking proves he is sane. Around him, officers profit and comrades die.
Marco Loristan lives in London with his exiled father, a Samavian patriot. With his friend the Rat, a street boy, Marco carries a secret sign across Europe to help restore Samavia's rightful king. The journey tests both boys' courage and loyalty as danger follows them from border to border.
During World War II, a young officer joins a worn-out minesweeper whose new captain, Queeg, grows increasingly erratic. When his executive officer relieves him during a typhoon, the Navy tries the officer for mutiny. The court-martial becomes a reckoning with loyalty, command and who is fit to lead.
Theseus grows up in Troizen believing the sea god is his father, then learns his true parentage and travels to Athens to claim his place. On the way he becomes the year-king of Eleusis, bound by an old sacrifice, and later goes to Crete, where he enters the labyrinth and faces the Minotaur.
Start with “The Searchers”, “True Grit”, “Lonesome Dove”: they are the closest to “Butcher's Crossing” in tropes and mood. Under each book in the list you will see what exactly it has in common.
How are similar books chosen?
We compare tropes (for “Butcher's Crossing” these are Wild West, Coming of Age, Survival), genre, plot, era and tone. It is not “readers also bought”; it is similarity in the content itself.
Are there recent books in this list?
Yes. Among the newer ones are “News of the World”, “The Revenant”, “The Sisters Brothers”. Switch the “Modern” filter to keep only books from 2000 onward.
