What to read after “Say Yes to the Duke” by Eloisa James: a list matched by tropes, mood and atmosphere. Under each book you will see what it has in common.
Valentine Layton, Duke of Malvern, bungles his proposal and his bride-to-be flees into the night. Her twin brother Bonny insists Valentine chase her to Dover, so the two set off together. On the road, Valentine begins to question everything he assumed about love, especially once an inn leaves them sharing a single bed.
Melisande Fleming has loved Lord Vale from a distance for years. When he is jilted at the altar, she offers to marry him, expecting a practical union and nothing more. Vale accepts, but his guarded bride proves more complicated than he imagined, and the secrets they both keep threaten the marriage.
Lady Calpurnia Hartwell has spent her life being proper and unremarkable. She draws up a list of scandalous things she longs to try and asks Gabriel St. John, the notorious Marquess of Ralston, to help her. As he escorts her through each escapade, an old acquaintance deepens into love.
Newland Archer is engaged to May Welland in old New York society when May's cousin, the Countess Olenska, returns from Europe after leaving her husband. Newland and the Countess are drawn to each other, but the rules of their world demand that he marry May and hide what he feels.
Lady Penelope Campion would rather stay home with her rescued animals than face London society. When her new neighbour, the ruthless businessman Gabriel Duke, demands she clear out the animals so he can sell his house, Penny strikes a bargain: she will rehome them if he can find each one a loving home. As he struggles to place a two-legged dog, a foul-mouthed parrot and a menagerie of other strays, the cold businessman and the shy spinster are thrown together, and both must reckon with old wounds.
Rachel Chu, an economics professor in New York, travels to Singapore for the summer wedding of her boyfriend's best friend. There she learns that Nick's family is one of the wealthiest in Asia, and that his mother has already judged her unsuitable. A comic look at money, family and the marriage market.
At ten, Miranda Cheever was told she had no great beauty to look forward to. At twenty, she is still quietly in love with Nigel Bevelstoke, the viscount who once comforted her and who now believes he is done with love. Her diary records a patient hope that he might finally see her as a woman.
Bridget Jones is thirty-something, single and determined to improve her life, recording every diet, cigarette and romantic disaster in her diary. Between her flirtatious boss and a stiff family friend, she tries to work out what she actually wants.
Penelope Featherington has watched Colin Bridgerton from the edge of every ballroom for years, certain he will never see her as more than his sister's friend. When Colin returns to London, their long acquaintance begins to change, and the secret behind the ton's anonymous gossip sheet threatens to upend them both.
Lady Felicity Faircloth was once the toast of London; now gossips have left her a spinster wallflower. A chance encounter with Devil, a powerful Covent Garden criminal, leads to a bargain: he will help her catch a duke if she helps him settle an old score. Neither expects the attraction that follows.
Daisy Bowman must find a husband this season or her father will send her to America. The suitor he has chosen is Matthew Swift, a cool businessman she has disliked for years, and as the two are thrown together in London, their old quarrel turns into something else.
Minerva Highwood, a bluestocking, needs to reach Scotland to present her geological discovery. The rake Lord Payne agrees to escort her, and they pose as eloping lovers to travel unnoticed. Four hundred miles of mishaps in a cramped carriage, and each night there is only one bed, turn their bickering into something neither expected.
Elizabeth Bennet has little patience for the proud Mr Darcy, whose fortune and manners make him an easy target for her wit. Their sparring slowly gives way to a truer understanding as family scandal and society threaten to keep them apart.
On a trip to Florence, young Lucy Honeychurch meets George Emerson, whose frankness unsettles the strict English manners she was raised to respect. Back in England, she must choose between a safe, conventional engagement and the feelings she has been taught to ignore.
Shy, penniless Fanny Price is raised at Mansfield Park as a poor relation, always aware of her place. Her only comfort is her cousin Edmund, whose attention shifts when the lively Mary Crawford arrives. Fanny must hold to her own judgment as the family's world of privilege and flirtation begins to unravel.
When Sophy Stanton-Lacy comes to stay with her cousins in London, she finds the household tangled in debts, broken engagements and bad tempers. Cheerful and managing, she sets out to arrange everyone's happiness, clashing with her proud cousin Charles along the way.
Alexander Moncrieffe, Duke of Falconbridge, finds his fiancée with another man and plans a cold revenge: seduce and abandon his rival's sister, Genevieve Eversea. At a country house party, the intelligent and overlooked Genevieve proves far more than he bargained for, and his scheme gives way to genuine feeling.
Shy Evie Jenner needs a husband to escape her greedy relatives and secure her inheritance. She proposes a marriage of convenience to Sebastian, Lord St. Vincent, a penniless rake with a scandalous reputation. They flee to Gretna Green, and the practical arrangement slowly turns into something neither of them expected.
Maybell inherits her great-aunt's crumbling house in the Smoky Mountains, only to learn the grouchy groundskeeper Wesley is a co-inheritor with very different plans. Forced to renovate together, the dreamer and the shy, scowling loner slowly find in each other the safety they have always wanted.
Valentine Napier, Duke of Montgomery, returns from exile to his London house, where his housekeeper Bridget Crumb is secretly searching for letters he uses to blackmail her mother. Valentine is vain, amoral and dangerous, yet Bridget refuses to be cowed. Their contest of wills becomes a slow, intense attraction.
Linda Radlett grows up in an eccentric upper-class family and spends her youth chasing the grand romance she has read about. Her cousin Fanny watches Linda move through marriages, affairs and wartime Paris, learning what love actually costs.
Minerva overhears her ex-boyfriend bet the charming Cal that he can get her into bed within a month, so she accepts his dinner invitation to turn the tables. The sceptical actuary and the commitment-shy businessman keep colliding through meddling friends and sheer bad luck, resisting an attraction neither of them wants.
Alexia Tarabotti is a spinster with no soul, which makes her immune to the supernatural. When a rogue vampire attacks her in steampunk London and a werewolf lord is sent to investigate, the two uncover a plot against the city's vampires and werewolves—and a mutual attraction neither of them expected.
Romance writer January and literary novelist Gus become summer neighbours in a lakeside town, both blocked and both skeptical of each other's genre. They make a bet to write in the other's style and slowly trade barbs for late-night talks, discovering the grief and hope behind their different worldviews.
Start with “Something Fabulous”, “To Seduce a Sinner”, “Nine Rules to Break When Romancing a Rake”: they are the closest to “Say Yes to the Duke” in tropes and mood. Under each book in the list you will see what exactly it has in common.
How are similar books chosen?
We compare tropes (for “Say Yes to the Duke” these are Wallflower Heroine, Grumpy Sunshine, Coming of Age), genre, plot, era and tone. It is not “readers also bought”; it is similarity in the content itself.
Are there recent books in this list?
Yes. Among the newer ones are “Something Fabulous”, “To Seduce a Sinner”, “Nine Rules to Break When Romancing a Rake”. Switch the “Modern” filter to keep only books from 2000 onward.
