Books like “The Murder at the Vicarage”

What to read after “The Murder at the Vicarage” by Agatha Christie: a list matched by tropes, mood and atmosphere. Under each book you will see what it has in common.

About “The Murder at the Vicarage”

Another favorite book?

Or start with a well-known book

1
The Red House Mystery
A. A. Milne · 1922
Similar atmosphere: “Cozy Mystery”
- Cozy Mystery
- Twist Ending
At a country house party, the host's brother is found shot in a locked room and the host has vanished. Antony Gillingham, a guest with a taste for detective stories, and his friend Bill play at being Holmes and Watson, poking into the household's secrets before the police arrive.
2
The Nine Tailors
Dorothy L. Sayers · 1934
Similar atmosphere: “Cozy Mystery”
Lord Peter Wimsey is stranded by floods in the fenland village of Fenchurch St Paul over New Year. Months later a battered body is found in a newly opened grave, and Wimsey must read the village's bell-ringing lore and an old jewel theft to give the dead man a name.
3
The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes
Arthur Conan Doyle · 1892
Similar atmosphere: “Cozy Mystery”
- Cozy Mystery
- Eccentric Detective
Twelve stories follow London's most observant detective and his friend Dr Watson as they untangle impossible crimes, strange clients and quiet suburban mysteries from their rooms on Baker Street.
4
The Innocence of Father Brown
G. K. Chesterton · 1911
Similar atmosphere: “Cozy Mystery”
A quiet Catholic priest with a mild manner and an eye for human nature solves impossible crimes that baffle the police. Across twelve stories he uncovers murderers, thieves and impostors, often relying on ordinary details that everyone else has overlooked.
5
The Moving Toyshop
Edmund Crispin · 1946
Similar atmosphere: “Cozy Mystery”
Poet Richard Cadogan arrives in Oxford, finds a woman's body in a toyshop and is knocked out. When he returns with the police the shop has become a grocer's. With his friend, eccentric professor Gervase Fen, he hunts for the vanished corpse and the trick behind the impossible scene.
6
Still Life
Louise Penny · 2005
Similar atmosphere: “Cozy Mystery”
- Cozy Mystery
- Small Town Secrets
In the village of Three Pines, the body of a well-liked woman is found in the woods with an arrow through her heart. Chief Inspector Armand Gamache is drawn into a community where old friendships and hidden resentments make almost everyone a suspect.
7
The Marlow Murder Club
Robert Thorogood · 2021
Similar atmosphere: “Cozy Mystery”
When Judith Potts hears a shot while swimming in the Thames near her home, the police see nothing strange. She teams up with a dog walker and a vicar's wife to investigate, and the three amateur sleuths begin to uncover the town's secrets.
8
The Thursday Murder Club
Richard Osman · 2020
Similar atmosphere: “Cozy Mystery”
Four friends in a retirement village meet weekly to look over unsolved crimes, until a murder happens on their doorstep. As the bodies add up, they use a lifetime's worth of skill and nosiness to work the case the police cannot close.
9
Too Many Cooks
Rex Stout · 1938
Similar atmosphere: “Cozy Mystery”
- Cozy Mystery
- Eccentric Detective
Nero Wolfe is lured out of his brownstone to a gathering of the world's great chefs, and one of them is poisoned. When the killer turns toward Wolfe himself, he and Archie Goodwin must sort through the guests of a secretive culinary society to name the murderer.
10
Magpie Murders
Anthony Horowitz · 2016
Similar atmosphere: “Cozy Mystery”
Editor Susan Ryeland receives the manuscript of the ninth Alan Conway mystery, but the last chapters are missing and the author is dead. As she reads the country-house puzzle inside the book, the writer's real quarrels and the missing pages draw her into a case of her own.
11
The Murder of Roger Ackroyd
Agatha Christie · 1926
Same genre: “Detective fiction”
In the village of King's Abbot, the wealthy Roger Ackroyd is stabbed hours after learning a secret. Hercule Poirot, retired nearby to grow marrows, is drawn into the case, where everyone, including the narrator, seems to be telling less than the whole truth.
12
Vera Wong's Unsolicited Advice for Murderers
Jesse Q. Sutanto · 2023
Similar atmosphere: “Cozy Mystery”
- Cozy Mystery
- Eccentric Detective
Vera Wong runs a quiet, failing tea shop in San Francisco's Chinatown. Finding a dead man on her floor, she decides the police will bungle it, takes charge of the case and invites the victim's circle to tea, feeding them and questioning them until the truth spills out.